PROSPECT STREET
BY DON MALCARNE, TOWN HISTORIAN
The Prospect Street area has been known by many names over the years.
Initially, the name "Pound Hill" comes to mind, for in the
latter part of the 18th century, a cattle and swine "pound' was in
evidence at the south end of this street. The primary reason for the
storing of these animals here was for shipment to other places,
primarily the West Indies. This was during the latter half of the 18th
century. Thereafter (the first part of the 19th century), and for
obvious reasons, this road was called Church Street, or "Zion
Hill", as the Episcopal, Baptist, & Methodist congregations met
here. By the middle of the 19th century the name Prospect had been
applied, and has stayed that way since.
An article in this paper about a year ago, discussed the
"shifting" center of Essex. The formation of Essex village
churches follows this pattern precisely. Originally, the main spiritual
focus was the First Congregational Church in Centerbrook, founded in
1722, with Abraham Nott as the first minister. With the sudden growth of
entreprenurialism in Essex after the Revolutionary War, centering on
ship building, a distinct expansion and change of spiritual preference
took place. Indeed, according to "A Statistical History of The
County of Middlesex" by Reverend David Dudley Field, published in
1819, Essex Village (Potapoug Point) and Middletown had the most
religious diversity south of Hartford.
The prime force behind this economic movement, Captain Uriah Hayden
(builder of the ship "Oliver Cromwell"), was paramount in the
establishment of the Episcopal Church in town. This congregation was
located in a building close to where the current Steam Train station is.
This was in the last decade of the 18th century. Within 10 years, this
building was physically moved to the southwest corner of Prospect
Street, where it served that congregation for almost 100 years. The
construction of the current St. Johns edifice on Main Street in 1897
(dedication) ended the stay of this denomination on "Church
Hill". The building was sold to the Catholic Church and became the
original "Our Lady of Sorrows". It was destroyed by fire in
1926, and the site of the old Pettipaug House (a former hotel and
dormitory for Hills Academy) was chosen for the new "Our Lady of
Sorrows". Interestingly enough, as the now newer "Our Lady of
Sorrows" was being constructed this past year, the foundation of
this structure revealed some of the original construction features of
1848.
In 1849, the Methodist Church was put up by carpenter Frederick
Gladding. This classic greek revival structure operated as a church well
into the 19th century. It was sold in 1945 to the Essex Fire Department
(ELR 29/390), and eventually became a warehouse for the local Verplex
Company. The front facade of the building was sold to a group in Long
Island, N.Y., but has since been reproduced, for it is now a private
residence. Before this building went up, the Methodists met in the
"Town Hall", now a dwelling house, just south of the Essex
Fire Department, on the east side of Prospect Street.
The building of the Congregational Church in 1852 completed a
triangle of churches on the south end of Prospect Street This was the
first break from the "mother" Congregational Church in
Centerbrook, and the building itself has been enlarged twice over the
last 43 years. Sea Captain Isaiah Pratt, whose home was originally
positioned where the Essex Post Office currently stands, specified in
his will that money he was leaving for the formation of a new high
school, be used for the education of children from this congregation
only. The trustees of that will therefore made Pratt High School
(current town hall) a type of private school, essentially charging
tuition, so all could attend. In effect, a use of the principle of the
separation of church and state.
The Egyptian Revival style Baptist Church, constructed in 1846 (with
a new and different tower in 1929), is actually the second Baptist
Meeting House on this hill. The original brick church was across the
street in the area of the Essex Fire Department parking lot. It was
built in 1817 with money contributed by Jared Hayden, and served the
Baptist congregation until the new church was built. It is prominently
shown in the famous "Barber" 1836 lithograph of Essex and
"Church Hill". In addition, a Baptist conference hall was put
up in 1837. This was sold to the town in 1845 for a school building and
was known as the "Point School" until being disbanded in 1910.
It exists today as The Essex Art Gallery.
In addition to the five denominations already mentioned, in 1947, the
Christian Science Society constructed a building between the old
so-called "Town Hall" and the Methodist Church building. This
was originally a one story contemporary structure and served that
congregation until 1964 when it was sold (ELR 49/375). The Christian
Science Church removed to the Old Post Road in Old Saybrook at that
time, and has been there since. This building has been altered several
times and remains a private residence.
Such is a very brief history of the churches in this area. It must
also be noted that the Congregational, Catholic and Baptist Churches
maintain parsonages on Prospect Street. Considering all this activity,
it is all the more interesting that the name was changed from Church
Street to Prospect Street. However, this hill does give a fine
"prospect" of the "Great River", and considering
that there were practically no trees when it was named as such, it was
probably a very logical move 160 years ago.
Although this article only features Prospect Street, the Essex
Historical Society will have a very special program on the evening of
January 28, 1998 in the cafeteria of the Essex Elementary School. Local
clerics from our three villages will be guest panelists, with this
author as moderator. Questions will be set forth by the moderator, and
audience participation will be encouraged. It promises to be a great
evening.