SAMUEL MERRITT COMSTOCK
BY DONALD MALCARNE. TOWN HISTORIAN
In light of the recent publication of "From Bicycles To Buicks",
an excellent history of the Behrens & Bushnell Company (now Town
& Country Auto Sales, Inc.) of Ivoryton by Michael Wells, it might
be prudent to look at the man who was essentially responsible for the
development of that village of our town, Samuel M. Comstock.
The Deep River New Era stated in the September 29, 1899 issue that
"If one would know the real history of Ivoryton, he should look up
and study the business history of the Comstock, Cheney, & Co., for
that firm is really the Ivoryton of today". Samuel Comstock was the
real founder of that company, as well as Ivoryton itself. Indeed, Beer's
1884 "History of Middlesex County" states that, "the
village of Ivoryton, which a few years ago was almost a wilderness, is
now one of the most beautiful villages in the state, and this has been
accomplished mainly through his (Samuel Comstock's) efforts".
Samuel Merritt Comstock was born in what was then the West
Centrebrook (old spelling) section of town (current Ivoryton), in the
second house past the Ivoryton Hotel , on August 14, 1809. He had 9
brothers and sisters, and his father (also Samuel) was a part time sea
captain, operating primarily in the West Indies trade. He went to work
for his uncle, Elisha Comstock in the combmaking trade at an early age,
both at where Centerbridge Books and Centerbrook Architects are now
located in the village of Centerbrook. By the time he was 25, he and a
business partner, Edwin Griswold formed the firm of Comstock &
Griswold, working off the dam behind the current Ivoryton Congregational
Church. As a matter of fact, they built almost identical homes on either
side of Brackett Lane (they are turned 90 degrees to each other) in
1838. This small area of town was then known as Whitesboro. They
continued to manufacture ivory combs here until 1847, when the firm was
dissolved and Comstock set up a new shop across from his boyhood home
further up the Falls River. This is where the so-called Ivory Shop
buildings still stand today. Mr. Comstock understood the need for an
adequate amount of water to power his plants. As a result he built a
succession of dams to harness the energy of the Falls River and other
streams. One of these dams, located on Bushy Hill, burst under the
duress of 15 inches of rain in June, 1982 causing untold damage, 110
years after it was built.
This new organization was the S. M. Comstock & Co., a family
firm, in which an endless variety of ivory products were manufactured,
from combs to billiard balls. Mr. Comstock was not only an astute
business person, but a renowned inventor of machinery used in
manufacturing ivory products. More importantly, he had a plan for this
section of our town, and when this was finally brought to fruition (by
his business partner, George A. Cheney), Ivoryton became a classic
example of a town designed around a factory. In 1851, he had built a new
home (adjacent to the Ivoryton Post Office to the east), and proceeded
to fulfill his dream. He had married Harriet Hovey of Mansfield, CT. in
1838, and had 11 children, although only 6 lived to adulthood. Some of
these offspring lived in currently prominent Ivoryton homesteads.
Archibald W. Comstock, mentioned in Michael Well's book, built what is
now the Copper Beech Inn as his home in the early 1890s. His brother,
and later President of the Comstock, Cheney, & Co., Robert H., lived
diagonally across the street in the home now occupied by the Grover
family, at the entrance to Riversedge Condominiums.
In 1862, the expansion of his company required more financing, and
the Comstock, Cheney, & Co. was formed, with a new investor, George
A. Cheney as an equal partner. In the early 1870s the so called
"upper shop" was built (and added to 3 times before 1900),
which handled the piano/organ business. This firm went on to be the
largest company in one town in Middlesex County (to 1900), and was one
of the largest producers of ivory products in the world. Stores, homes,
amusements, schools, etc. were built in Ivoryton by the company for
their employees, in a classic display of welfare capitalism. Mr.
Comstock never really saw all of this happen however, for he died in
Wilmington, North Carolina on January 18, 1878. As indicated earlier,
George Cheney became the head of the company at Comstock's death and
carried it to its great size and importance. The legacy Samuel Comstock
left was tremendous however, for Ivoryton remained a superb example of
the culture of the Industrial Revolution. In 1936 the great depression
had taken a terrible toll economically and Comstock, Cheney, & Co.
combined with the Pratt, Read & Co. of Deep River, forever after to
be known by the name of that Deep River firm. All of the non factory
assets of the Comstock, Cheney, & Co., from the Ivoryton Playhouse
to the 1838 house built by Samuel Comstock, were transferred to the
Ivoryton Realty Co., created specifically to sell all this property.
Samuel Comstock's dreams had become victim to the realities of 20th
century economics and societies.